Not all of our delicious goodies are available online. If you don't find what you are looking for give us a call at 608-831-2032 and we can help. Our Middleton store is open Mon - Sat, 7AM - 5 PM

Homestyle Cookies

Homestyle Cookie Sale

Buy One 4-Pack ~ Get One 4-Pack Free

Sale Ends Aug. 31, 2026

Limit 2- Free 4-Packs (8 cookies)

Must put at least 2 - 4 packs in your cart to get the discount. 

5 products
  • Two chocolate chip cookies on a white plate.
    $13.96
    $13.96
    Sold out or Seasonal Only
  • Pokie Cookies 4-Pack
    $13.96
    $13.96
    Sold out or Seasonal Only
  • Reeses Peanut Butter Cup Cookies 4-Pack
    $13.96
    $13.96
    Sold out or Seasonal Only
  • Snickerdoodle Cookies 4-Pack
    $13.96
    $13.96
    Sold out or Seasonal Only
  • Two cookies with chocolate chips and toffee bits on a stone surface
    $13.96
    $13.96
    Sold out or Seasonal Only